Artifact 723af954e93758bc5cf89f27f6de355b53bd08368d93c46734ff32a9d32c1353:
- File
conformance/rfcs/README.md
— part of check-in
[a68f89e414]
at
2026-10-22 00:03:56
on branch feat/horizon-cones
— conform(horizon): pin at horizon-rfc bbd1435674; the leaves rule over P cards
zit's author called horizon-rfc bbd1435674 ready to implement against, and zit#265 settled the leaves rule there against fossil's leaf: a childless check-in is one no P card names, open or closed, and K under the leaves rule is C's descendants plus every descendant of each check-in where a childless check-in's ancestry meets C's. Both rules now yield a set closed under descendants, so leaves and branch tips derive exactly.
HeldSet follows zit's computation at that check-in (src/sparse.zig, ClassifyState.extend): meeting points are the members of C's ancestry a childless check-in's parent walk reaches without passing one, and a childless check-in is skipped only when it descends from C. The tests that encoded the old rule are restated: a merged-but-open branch tip adds nothing, a closed branch's tip does, the fork's descendants on C's side are held, and an unrelated root adds nothing.
The draft copy, the README pin and the table follow: HZ-3.1-1, HZ-5.2-1 (the seed applies to every entry of K) and HZ-6.2-11 (announce only in reply to a request that pulls) are restated, and HZ-3.1-4 (closure under descendants) is new, with a case checking that no child of a held check-in falls outside K under either rule. (user: [email protected], size: 4489) [annotate] [blame] [check-ins using] [more...]
Pinned drafts
The conformance suite reads these documents, never edits them. Each is a
byte-for-byte copy of a file under docs/rfcs/ in the zit repository, taken
from the check-in below. The requirements tables in ../requirements/ pin
each copy by its SHA-256, so a refreshed copy fails the coverage test until
its table has been re-read against it.
The draft text is the authority. Since zit check-in 62a7d1bb3f
(2026-10-20) every erratum is applied in its draft and zit keeps no
erratum files: each draft records its corrections in its own Changes
appendix ("Changes in This Revision").
Since zit check-in 68a3f76cb7 (2026-10-20) the artifact-format,
repo-state and sync-protocol drafts name themselves -00 throughout, in
their headers, their cross-references and their reference entries, and the
copies here carry zit's file names. Against the 62a7d1bb3f text, which
these copies replace, nothing but those names and the wording of the
Changes appendix's heading and introduction differs: no normative text
changed and no section number moved.
| File | zit check-in | zit artifact | SHA-256 |
|---|---|---|---|
draft-fossil-artifact-format-00.txt |
68a3f76cb7 |
aa13f2e42c |
0887d83d3c57c8b1… |
draft-fossil-repo-state-00.txt |
68a3f76cb7 |
140fdf2d3b |
137f0a573498bf27… |
draft-fossil-sync-protocol-00.txt |
68a3f76cb7 |
62e9495f35 |
2195d9a18fe6bfaa… |
draft-fossil-delta-format-00.txt |
62a7d1bb3f |
d8025d6d75 |
6a28ee7e2e146f80… |
draft-fossil-submanifests-00.txt |
e03d91943e57afa20c3fdeab159a23a8a5eab66c (branch horizon-rfc) |
b9b19fa418 |
99ea094690fe1386… |
draft-fossil-sparse-cone-00.txt |
e6ee276c89 (branch horizon-rfc) |
c7ef80e7e1 |
2ecfc54f4b830938… |
draft-fossil-horizon-00.txt |
bbd1435674 (branch horizon-rfc) |
05edfa9e5e |
2e1002e1137ba99f… |
The delta-format and sub-manifest files are byte-identical at 68a3f76cb7
and 62a7d1bb3f. The delta-format draft is unchanged since 3f86ff4261
(2026-10-17).
The sub-manifest draft (draft-fossil-submanifests-00) includes the sparse
canonical-rewrite correction merged into horizon-rfc at the exact check-in
above (2026-10-20). Sections 6.2 and 6.4 require canonical construction under
the requested k, including MAX-cut shifts, final-small-group merges and
propagation at every height. Opaque reuse requires verified compatible
partition evidence, not the mutable setting; missing necessary nodes must
be fetched or cause explicit refusal without a partial check-in. Appendix
A.6 supplies the required MAX, final-merge and different/unknown-k cases.
The earlier Appendix A byte vectors in ../testdata/submanifest/ remain
unchanged: they are zit's src/rfc_vectors/ copies from 3f86ff4261, each
with two leading # lines that the suite drops.
The sparse-cone and horizon drafts follow zit's horizon-rfc branch, where
the horizon draft lives; that branch merges trunk. The sparse-cone copy at
e6ee276c89 carries the corrections of zit #257 to #260 and #262 (the
cone-served acknowledgement, the empty-cone refusal, structural retention
on compaction and local filtering, and the pull-inventory clarifications)
and retains the branch's §3.1
members-of-other-kinds and §6.2 outside-delta-base corrections. Its §4.2
now requires the complete canonical structural affected range and verified
partition basis, with fetch or explicit refusal when necessary nodes are
absent. Section 5.1 permits outside payloads to be absent but does not
require discarding already-held or demand-fetched payloads; §5.3 follows
the corrected canonical-writing contract. The horizon copy is pinned at
bbd1435674, the revision zit's author called ready to implement against
(2026-10-21); the sparse-cone text there is byte-identical to the copy at
e6ee276c89. Its Appendix C lists every change to the earlier text: the
leaves rule restated over P cards alone, with K closed under descendants
under both rules (§3.1, §3.4); the seed carrying T cards for every entry
of K, not C alone (§5.2.1); the cursor's announcements made only in reply
to a request that pulls (§6.2.6); and, from the revision before, the
cursor itself and the classification-memoization SHOULDs (§6.1, §6.2). The same
branch adds the pragma names these two drafts define (cone, cone-not,
and the horizon family) to the sync draft's §9 list of extension pragmas;
the sync draft here follows trunk, so that addition is pending.